The article argues that "race realism," the view that innate racial differences explain differences in intelligence, is not supported by modern genetics or science. It was written by authors who say the claims are re-emerging in Western politics and being repeated in some academic journals.
The piece cites Donald Trump's remark at the World Economic Forum in Davos that people from Somalia have "low IQs," and says that his son, Donald Trump Jr., made a similar statement about Haitian people in 2024. The article notes that the US government has since ended the protected status of Somali and Haitian migrants.
The authors name Nathan Cofnas as a figure in this network, noting that he recently accused the late Jason Arday of plagiarism. They say some people in the network are affiliated with universities. They argue that these researchers publish work in a handful of mainstream academic journals, and that the work is methodologically flawed.
The authors cite Richard Lewontin's 1970s finding that there is more genetic variation within human groups than between them. They argue that socially defined racial groups do not map neatly onto genetic clusters. They also point to ancient DNA research showing constant mixing between human groups.
On IQ data, the article says the "national IQ" database that hereditarians rely on has been shown by researchers to be methodologically flawed. The authors also cite the Flynn effect, the documented rise in IQ scores over the 20th and 21st centuries, which they argue points to environmental rather than genetic causes.