Amazon's refreshed Kindle lineup makes a clear case for color, but it does not make a clear case for buying it. The Colorsoft's Signature Edition costs $320, and the base Colorsoft starts at $290. The reviewer tested the Signature Edition for several weeks and found it well made, with an aluminum back that held up and a design that is lighter and thinner than the first-generation model.

The strongest argument for the Colorsoft is its screen. Standard Kindles show everything in black and white, while the Colorsoft brings out original colors, which matters for comics, graphic novels, cookbooks, and readers who highlight passages in different colors. The reviewer also notes that the colors are muted compared with an iPad, though they still make a noticeable difference. Adjustable color temperature, auto-adjusting brightness, a waterproof body, and a relocated power button add practical value, and the reviewer found the screen refreshed infrequently and showed no noticeable ghosting.

The problem is the price relative to the use. The report describes the Colorsoft as a steep investment for a device used only for reading. Battery life is up to eight weeks, compared with up to 12 weeks for the Paperwhite, which is still long for everyday electronics but shorter than the Paperwhite's. The reviewer could not assess the magnetic case with page-turn buttons because no case was available for testing, so that feature cannot be counted in the device's favor.

Amazon should be judged on who the product is for. If you already own the first-generation Colorsoft, the report says there is little reason to upgrade. If you want color for comics or cookbooks, the Colorsoft is worth considering despite its cost. For everyone else, the basic Kindle at $169.99 or the Paperwhite at $199.99 will likely serve better. The Colorsoft is a nice upgrade, but it is not a must-have, and readers should not pay a premium for a feature they will rarely use.