When Google told schools that they could not turn off its Gemini-powered AI features without also losing Search, it made a choice that schools should not accept. According to The New York Times, the company said that starting next year, schools will not have the option to disable Gemini-powered features without also disabling Search. Chris Phillips, Google's vice president of education, put the logic plainly: "Search and AI are deeply integrated," and schools that turn off the AI features "will not have access to Search." That is not a product feature. It is a bundling decision, and it puts districts in the position of choosing between tools they need and tools they have doubts about.
The reaction from officials was sharp. New York City Mayor Zohran Mamdani and Senator Bernie Sanders called Google's behavior "extortion." The word is strong, but the pressure it describes is real. New York City schools chancellor Kamar H. Samuels said that if Google does not reconsider, the district will explore other search options. Chicago's public schools have reportedly given the same message. Districts with budgets and student bodies of this size are not making an idle threat, and a company that depends on classroom reach should take it seriously.
Google's response, given to The Verge through spokesperson Laura Breen, points to a useful concession. The company said it heard parents and teachers worry about students using AI to shortcut learning, and it said that Gemini app, Gemini Notebook and Search will be off by default until schools decide which services to enable. That default is the right one. The problem is that the reversal arrived only after the pressure did, and the pilot of Guided Learning in Search is still a pilot. Schools should not have to bargain for the basic ability to decline a product they did not ask for.
Educators have concrete reasons for caution. Some studies have shown that students who use AI generally perform worse on tests, and there are concerns about children developing relationships with chatbots at a young age. Those concerns are the reason districts want control, and control is what the bundled model removes. Google's embedding in classrooms, through Google Classroom and Chromebooks, is also a reason to be wary of dependence, not a reason to surrender the choice.
Districts should keep pressing for a Search that works without AI features unless they choose them, and they should write that requirement into contracts. Going Google-free may be hard, as the report notes, but the first step is simple: refuse to accept a bundle as the price of a basic service. Schools decide what their students use, not the vendor.